Surge in Non-Permanent Residents: IRCC’s Ongoing Challenge

Author: Al Parsai, LL.M, RCIC-IRB

Last Updated On: August 15, 2024

Canada faces increasing difficulty in managing its growing Non-Permanent Residents (NPRs) population. Their rise directly affects the job and housing market. More concerning, however, is the shift in how Canadians perceive immigrants as frustrations grow. This article delves into the NPR surge since 2022 and critically examines the government’s recent efforts to address this complex challenge.

Understanding Non-Permanent Residents (NPRs) in Canada

Non-Permanent Residents (NPRs) play a significant role in Canada but differ from permanent residents and citizens in important ways. NPRs reside in Canada temporarily and hold specific permits or statuses. Below is a breakdown of the different categories of NPRs based on the Statistics Canada definitions:

Work Permit Holders

• Who They Are: These individuals have received authorization to work in Canada for a set period. Furthermore, they hold an LMIA-based or an LMIA-exempt work permit.
• Purpose: Canada issues work permits to fill labour shortages, particularly in industries that require specialized skills or temporary labour. Work permits might be employer-specific or open, allowing the holder to work for any employer.
• Impact: Work permit holders contribute to the economy by filling essential job roles, especially in sectors like agriculture, technology, and healthcare.

Study Permit Holders

• Who They Are: These individuals enter Canada to pursue education at Canadian institutions, including universities, colleges, and primary or secondary schools.
• Purpose: Study permits enable international students to study in Canada. Our country values these students for the cultural diversity and economic benefits they bring.
• Impact: Study permit holders contribute significantly to the education sector and local economies. They also represent a potential future workforce, as many transition to permanent residency after completing their studies.

Refugee Claimants (Asylum Seekers)

• Who They Are: Refugee claimants have fled their home countries due to persecution, conflict, or violence and seek asylum in Canada.
• Purpose: They apply for refugee status, seeking Canadian and international law protection. While their claims are processed, they remain in Canada as NPRs.
• Impact: While refugee claimants add to the diversity of Canadian society, they also require support services, including housing, legal aid, and healthcare. Their eventual integration depends on the outcome of their refugee claims.

Protected Persons

• Who They Are: Individuals whose refugee claims have been accepted, granting them protection in Canada.
• Purpose: Protected persons have demonstrated a genuine need for protection due to the risk of persecution or danger in their home countries. They have not yet achieved permanent resident status but live in Canada legally.
• Impact: Protected persons contribute to Canadian society by working, studying, and integrating into communities. They often move towards permanent residency, contributing long-term to the country’s demographic and economic landscape.

Family Members of Work and Study Permit Holders

• Who They Are: These individuals are the spouses, partners, or children of work or study permit holders accompanying them to Canada.
• Purpose: While primarily in Canada to support or join their family members, they may also work or study, depending on their specific permits.
• Impact: These family members contribute to community diversity and the local economy. However, they do not change the primary permit holder’s NPR status.

Non-Permanent Residents (NPRs) encompass many individuals with specific roles and impacts within Canadian society. From workers filling crucial labour gaps to students enriching educational environments, NPRs are vital to Canada’s economic and cultural fabric. Understanding who they are and their contributions helps frame the broader discussion on managing this growing population segment.

The Growth of NPRs in Canada Since 2022

Canada has seen a significant surge in Non-Permanent Residents (NPRs) since 2022. This growth has been consistent and notable across various quarters, highlighting the challenges in managing this population. Let’s examine the trends in detail. The following image reflects the steady growth of NPRs since early 2022. Moreover, we have explored Quarter the Quarter growth of these groups (source: Statistics Canada).

Early Growth: 2022

The year 2022 marked the beginning of a substantial increase in NPR numbers. In Q1 2022, Canada recorded 1,356,622 NPRs. By Q2 2022, this number grew slightly to 1,370,985, reflecting a steady increase. However, the real surge began in Q3 2022, when the NPR population jumped to 1,500,978. This quarter-over-quarter growth rate was significant, indicating the beginning of a larger trend. By Q4 2022, the number reached 1,706,747, further underscoring the upward momentum.

Accelerated Growth: 2023

The trend continued into 2023, with even more pronounced growth. In Q1 2023, the NPR population surged to 1,856,883, a notable increase from the previous quarter. This trend continued in Q2 2023, when the population grew to 1,965,318. The growth did not stop here. By Q3 2023, the number of NPRs had reached 2,198,679, showing a significant leap. The year ended with Q4 2023, when the population soared to 2,511,437, marking a peak in the growth trend.

Recent Trends: 2024

Entering 2024, the NPR population continued to rise, albeit slower. In Q1 2024, the population increased to 2,661,784. This slower growth rate suggested that earlier interventions may have started taking effect. However, the numbers still climbed, with Q2 2024 recording 2,793,594 NPRs. Although the rate of increase has slowed, the overall trend remains upward.

Overall Trends

Since 2022, the NPR population in Canada has grown significantly. The most rapid increases occurred in 2022 and 2023, with some moderation seen in 2024. Despite government efforts to manage this growth, the numbers continue to rise, posing ongoing challenges for policymakers.

Government Targets and Efforts to Reduce Non-Permanent Residents (NPRs)

The Canadian government has set ambitious targets to curb this trend in response to the rapid growth of NPRs. According to CBC, Immigration Minister Marc Miller announced in March 2024 that the government aims to reduce the NPR population from 6.2% of Canada’s population in 2023 to 5% by 2027. This reduction would require a 19% decrease in NPR numbers, a significant challenge given the current growth trends. Notably, since that report, the NPR population has reached about 6.8% of the population.

IRCC Announcement in January 2024

In January 2024, Immigration, Refugees, and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) introduced measures to control the NPR population. They implemented a two-year cap on international student permits, a major contributor to the NPR population. By limiting the number of study permits issued to around 360,000 annually, the government aimed to stabilize this segment. Additionally, they tightened work permit regulations and reduced the validity of new Labour Market Impact Assessments (LMIAs) to six months, emphasizing the need for employers to prioritize Canadian workers.

Employment Sector Adjustments

Employment Minister Randy Boissonnault announced changes to the Temporary Foreign Worker Program (TFWP). Starting in May 2024, the government reduced the cap on low-wage temporary foreign workers in most sectors from 30% to 20% of the workforce. However, the construction and healthcare sectors retained the 30% cap due to ongoing labour shortages. Seasonal industries, such as agriculture and tourism, remained exempt during peak seasons. These adjustments aimed to better align the TFWP with Canada’s labour market needs and reduce dependence on temporary foreign workers.

Current Status and Challenges

Despite these efforts, the NPR population continued to grow. From December 2023 to June 2024, the NPR population increased by about 300,000, reaching nearly 2.8 million by mid-2024. This rise indicates that while the government’s measures are in place, they have not yet reversed the upward trend. The ambitious target to reduce the NPR population by 19% by 2027 remains challenging. Continued monitoring and possibly further adjustments will be necessary to achieve the desired outcomes.

Future Outlook: Potential for More Restrictions

Given the persistent growth in the Non-Permanent Resident (NPR) population, despite current government efforts, it seems likely that more restrictive measures may be on the horizon. The government’s ambitious goal to reduce the NPR population by 19% by 2027 has proven challenging. The continued increase in NPR numbers suggests that existing policies may not suffice to meet these targets. Therefore, it is reasonable to predict that the government will impose additional restrictions, potentially further tightening permits or introducing new regulations to control the influx of temporary residents. As Canada navigates this complex issue, we can expect ongoing adjustments in policy to achieve a more balanced immigration system.

Fill our Free Canada Immigration Assessment Form in your language!